Perception Matters
When it comes to force investigations and internal review, the who, what, when, and where are often the easiest questions to answer. Much of that information is readily available through body-worn camera footage, witness statements, reports, and other evidence.
As police officers, we are investigators. We are trained to observe, assess circumstances, gather information, and make decisions, often under rapidly changing and stressful conditions. Those same investigative skills become critical when documenting and explaining a use-of-force incident.
Clearly explaining those decisions becomes even more important because use-of-force decisions are frequently made in a time-compressed environment. Officers may have only fractions of a second to perceive a threat, interpret what is happening, decide, and act. That decision-making process needs to be clearly articulated during the investigation and in the resulting documentation.
The availability of body-worn camera footage has changed the way force incidents are investigated. Video can provide valuable evidence and help establish what occurred, but it doesn't tell the entire story.
Officers can't rely solely on body-worn camera footage to communicate their perception of an event. Statements such as, "I was in fear for my life," without an explanation of what specifically caused that perception, provide little insight into the officer's decision-making process. The "why" needs to be articulated.
An effective report should allow an investigator to understand the incident as though the video evidence were not available. The officer should explain what they observed, what they perceived, what they believed was occurring, how they interpreted the subject's actions, and how those factors influenced their decisions.
Body-worn cameras record an event, but they do not necessarily record the event exactly as the officer experienced it. A camera has a limited field of view. It does not necessarily capture everything the officer sees, hears, feels, or processes. Camera position, lighting, distance, movement, frame rate, perspective, and other technological limitations can affect what appears in the recording.
There is also a fundamental difference between what a camera records and what a human perceives. A camera captures images. An officer is processing an environment.
During a critical event, the human brain does not necessarily process every available piece of information equally. Attention is directed toward what the person perceives as most important at that moment.
As a result, an officer may see or hear something without consciously processing it or later remembering it as part of the event. Likewise, information that is clearly visible or audible on video may not have been perceived by the officer at the time. This distinction is important during an internal review.
Investigators often ask: If an action or detail is clearly visible on the video, how could the officer not have seen it? The answer is that being present in the camera's field of view does not necessarily mean the information entered the officer's perception or memory.
Time compression, distance, speed, attentional focus, environmental conditions, stress, and human performance limitations can all influence perception and memory during critical incidents.
There is another potential concern when officers review video after an incident. Information that was not originally perceived or remembered may become incorporated into the officer's recollection simply because it is visible on the recording. That creates an important distinction between what the video shows and what the officer perceived at the time.
For that reason, investigators and officers should recognize that video evidence is an important piece of an investigation, but it should not automatically be treated as a perfect representation of the officer's experience. Officers should not assume that the video will speak for them.
The video may show the subject's movements. It may show the officer's actions. It may establish the sequence of events. But it can't explain the officer's perception or the thought process that connected those observations to a decision. That explanation must come from the officer. The goal is not simply to document what happened. It is to document why it happened from the officer's perspective at the time the decision was made.


